Is Usain Bolt The Greatest Athlete of All Time? That’s not What The Numbers Say
Kate R. Saunders, Alec G. Stephenson, 14 Aug 17
       

The Bolt – Usain Bolt – after coming third in the men’s 100m final at the World Athletics Championships in London. Reuters/Fabrizio Bensch

Usain Bolt has finally hung up his running shoes, retiring from athletics amid plaudits hailing him as the greatest athlete and greatest champion of all time.

While it wasn’t quite the fairy tale ending in Bolt’s final race – he came third and claimed only bronze in the 100m final at the IAAF World Athletics Championships in London – his overall career results are certainly fit for the record books.

The final sprint race for Usain Bolt saw him bring in the bronze.

He is the fastest runner in history over 100m and 200m, as well as winning the “triple triple” at the Olympics: gold in the 100m, 200m and 4x100m relay at three consecutive games, in Beijing, London and Rio. (The Beijing 2008 4x100m relay gold was later revoked after his team mate Nesta Carter was disqualified for failing a drug test.)

Bolt also held the world championship title over these distances between 2009 and 2015, with the exception of one false start in the 100m in 2011.

But is the Jamaican athlete the greatest of all time, as is often claimed?

Is he the greatest? Usain Bolt’s not used to picking up the bronze medal as he did after his final 100m race when Justin Gatlin took gold at the World Athletics Championships in London. Reuters/Phil Noble

How to compare athletes

This is an interesting question given how the athletics world has changed over time.

Athletes today have access to cutting-edge training methods, nutrition plans and scientific and technological advancements in equipment such as track composition and footwear. There have also been improvements in measuring an athlete’s performance during a race.

The performance of past 100m winners could be influenced by a number of things such as race conditions and scientific advantages that were available at the time.

For Bolt to truly deserve the title of “greatest of all time”, we need to compare his results to those of previous athletes over the 100m. We also need to compare his track performances to the fastest times over the other track distances. We can do this using statistics.

If we look at the fastest 100m race times for each year, we see there has been a large decrease in fastest times for both men and women.

This pattern of decreasing times is observed for race times across all distances. A key reason in the decrease in race times is due to advances in modern training and scientific knowledge. In our statistical model, we include a changing trend in time so we can compare athlete performances in different years.

We also need to include adjustments in our statistical model for environmental and political factors that influence the population from which athletes are. During World War I and World War II, for example, the pool of athletes was depleted by men away fighting for their country.

The statistical model that we used, that includes both the trend in time and adjustment for population influences, is called a Weibull distribution.

This distribution is perfect for calculating the probability of rare events occurring in a given year, such as the fastest race times, and is ideal for estimating the probability of breaking world records.

Crunch the numbers

We use this distribution to model the fastest race times each year over the distances 100m, 200m, 400m, 800m, 1500m, 5000m and 10,000m. Using the statistical properties of the distribution, we can then rescale to compare different athletes’ performances over different distances. This means we can answer the question: is Usain Bolt the greatest athlete of all time?

The top 10 rankings from the statistical model are given below. These rankings account for the advantage of racing in different years and account for performances over different distances.


Bolt is the world’s fastest man of all time over 100m and 200m but the title of world’s greatest athlete goes to Lee Evans of the United States, who broke the world record in the mens 400m at the Olympics in 1968 in Mexico City.

Lee Evans wins the race and a new world record.


Griffith-Joyner’s 100m world record time of 10.49s was suspected to be wind-assisted. But she also ran the second- and third-fastest official times in history for the women’s 100m, at 10.61s and 10.62s, so the title is well deserved.

Sign in to view full article

       
The Dead End of Communism
Communism is estimated to have killed at least 100 million people, yet its crimes have not been compiled and its ...
Epoch Times
Sat, 11 Feb 17
The Science of Gossip: Four Ways to Make it Less Toxic
Gossip gets a bad rap. There’s no doubt that the act of gossiping about someone can sometimes be damaging and ...
Jenny Cole
Sat, 1 Apr 17
Young Workers Expect Their Older Colleagues to Get Out of The Way
There are many names for the narratives pitting the older generation against the younger: Gen-Y versus Baby Boomers, “Generation Me” ...
Michael North
Wed, 15 Mar 17
Is The Developed World We’ve Created Giving Us Cancer?
I had assumed that the small lump in my breast was a blocked milk duct from nursing my seven-month-old son. ...
Chelsey Kivland
Thu, 8 Jun 17
Why are We More Likely to Get Cancer as We Age?
This article is part of our series on older people’s health. It looks at the changes and processes that occur ...
Stuart Pitson
Wed, 1 Feb 17
Hachi.Tech
Join us today!
At Epoch Times, We Care :o)
BUCHERER
Sports Elements
Read about Forced Organ Harvesting